Vi anbefaler

Vandana Shiva avslørt

Den indiske miljøaktivisten Vandana Shiva er en helt for store deler av venstresiden og den grønne bevegelse i Vesten. (Hun er æresdoktor ved Universitetet i Oslo - les prorektor Inga Bolstads rosende omtale her). Særlig kjent er hun for kampen mot GMO og påstandene om at genmodifisert bomull -…

Den indiske miljøaktivisten Vandana Shiva er en helt for store deler av venstresiden og den grønne bevegelse i Vesten. (Hun er æresdoktor ved Universitetet i Oslo – les prorektor Inga Bolstads rosende omtale her). Særlig kjent er hun for kampen mot GMO og påstandene om at genmodifisert bomull – Bt Cotton – har drevet indiske bønder til en selvmordsbølge.

I en lang og grundig artikkel i The New Yorker tar Michael Specter for seg Shivas mange påstander, og holder dem opp mot hva forskningen sier. Et par utdrag:

«At times, Shiva’s absolutism about G.M.O.s can lead her in strange directions. In 1999, ten thousand people were killed and millions were left homeless when a cyclone hit India’s eastern coastal state of Orissa. When the U.S. government dispatched grain and soy to help feed the desperate victims, Shiva held a news conference in New Delhi and said that the donation was proof that “the United States has been using the Orissa victims as guinea pigs” for genetically engineered products. She also wrote to the international relief agency Oxfam to say that she hoped it wasn’t planning to send genetically modified foods to feed the starving survivors. When neither the U.S. nor Oxfam altered its plans, she condemned the Indian government for accepting the provisions. (…)

Shiva refers to her scientific credentials in almost every appearance, yet she often dispenses with the conventions of scientific inquiry. She is usually described in interviews and on television as a nuclear physicist, a quantum physicist, or a world-renowned physicist. Most of her book jackets include the following biographical note: “Before becoming an activist, Vandana Shiva was one of India’s leading physicists.” When I asked if she had ever worked as a physicist, she suggested that I search for the answer on Google. I found nothing, and she doesn’t list any such position in her biography. (….)

The World Health Organization has estimated that a hundred and seventy thousand Indians commit suicide each year—nearly five hundred a day. Although many Indian farmers kill themselves, their suicide rate has not risen in a decade, according to a study by Ian Plewis, of the University of Manchester. In fact, the suicide rate among Indian farmers is lower than for other Indians and is comparable to that among French farmers. Plewis found that “the pattern of changes in suicide rates over the last fifteen years is consistent with a beneficial effect of Bt cotton for India as a whole, albeit perhaps not in every cotton-growing state. (…)

In a recent speech, Shiva explained why she rejects studies suggesting that genetically engineered products like Pental’s mustard oil are safe. Monsanto, she said, had simply paid for false stories, and “now they control the entire scientific literature of the world.” Nature, Science, and Scientific American, three widely admired publications, “have just become extensions of their propaganda. There is no independent science left in the world.”

Jan Arild Snoen

Bli abonnent

Da får du tilgang til alle artikler. Det tar under ett minutt.

Prøv i en måned for 1,-
Allerede abonnent? Logg inn

Fra forsiden